What is the Difference Between AEDP vs EMDR? [And Why do They Work so Well Together?]

Written By Liz Davis

While Accelerated Experiential Dynamic Psychotherapy (AEDP) and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) are both therapeutic options for treating trauma, the difference is that AEDP is an overarching methodology and EMDR is a specific treatment.

What is AEDP?

AEDP is a methodology centered on emotional processing that focuses on the transformational theory of change. It is characterized by its emphasis on creating safety and secure attachment within the therapeutic relationship. This approach facilitates the exploration and processing of emotional experiences, particularly those that are deeply rooted in trauma and relational difficulties.

  • Emphasis on Relationship: AEDP therapists focus heavily on developing a secure and healing relationship with their clients. The therapeutic relationship itself is used as a tool for healing.

  • Experiential Approach: AEDP involves working with emotions in the here-and-now, helping clients to not only talk about their feelings but also experience them in a safe and supportive environment.

  • Transformation-Oriented: The goal of AEDP is to help clients transform their suffering into self-acceptance and empowerment, fostering resilience and positive growth.

What is EMDR?

EMDR is a specific treatment primarily known for its effectiveness in processing and integrating traumatic memories. It employs a structured eight-phase approach that uses bilateral stimulation, typically through guided eye movements, to help the brain reprocess traumatic experiences.

  • Targeted Trauma Processing: EMDR directly targets the unprocessed memories that are at the root of trauma-related disorders, facilitating their reprocessing and integration in the brain.

  • Bilateral Stimulation: The use of eye movements or other forms of bilateral stimulation is a distinctive feature of EMDR, designed to activate both hemispheres of the brain, aiding in emotional processing.

  • Phased Structure: EMDR follows a specific set of steps that guide the client from initial assessment through to the integration of traumatic memories.

Key Differences between AEDP and EMDR

  • Focus and Application: While AEDP is more broadly focused on emotional healing and attachment issues, EMDR has a specific focus on memory processing, particularly for trauma.

  • Techniques and Interventions: AEDP uses the therapeutic relationship and experiential interventions as its primary tools, whereas EMDR employs structured protocols, including bilateral stimulation.

  • Therapeutic Outcomes: The outcomes of AEDP are centered around emotional transformation and attachment repair, while EMDR aims more at desensitization and reprocessing of traumatic memories.

  • Duration and Course of Treatment: AEDP may vary in length depending on the depth of emotional work, while EMDR can sometimes offer a quicker resolution of specific traumatic memories.

Common Conditions Treated with AEDP and EMDR

The therapeutic approaches of Accelerated Experiential Dynamic Psychotherapy (AEDP) and Eye Movement Desensitization and Reprocessing (EMDR) are both highly effective in treating a range of psychological conditions. While they have distinct methodologies, their application often overlaps in addressing various mental health issues. Below are some of the common conditions that AEDP and EMDR are used to treat:

Trauma and Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder (PTSD)

Both AEDP and EMDR are particularly renowned for their effectiveness in treating trauma and PTSD. EMDR directly targets the unprocessed memories that are the root of trauma-related disorders, facilitating their reprocessing and integration. AEDP, with its focus on secure attachment and emotional processing, also aids in healing the relational and emotional aspects of trauma.

Anxiety Disorders

AEDP and EMDR can be beneficial for individuals suffering from various anxiety disorders. AEDP helps in exploring and transforming underlying emotional drivers of anxiety, promoting resilience and self-regulation. EMDR, by processing anxiety-provoking memories, can alleviate the intensity of anxious responses.

Depression

Depression, often linked to unresolved emotional issues or traumatic experiences, can be effectively addressed by both AEDP and EMDR. AEDP facilitates the exploration and release of repressed emotions and feelings of unworthiness that often underlie depression. EMDR helps in reprocessing past events that contribute to depressive symptoms, allowing for a more adaptive understanding and integration of these experiences.

Grief and Loss

The grieving process can be complex, especially when it becomes prolonged or complicated. AEDP, with its empathetic and validating approach, helps individuals process feelings of loss and foster internal strength. EMDR can be used to process traumatic aspects of a loss, aiding in the natural grieving process.

Attachment Disorders

AEDP is particularly effective in treating attachment disorders due to its emphasis on creating a secure therapeutic relationship and exploring relational patterns. It helps clients understand and rework their attachment style, leading to more fulfilling relationships.

Dissociative Disorders

EMDR is known for its ability to help with dissociative disorders, especially when these are rooted in trauma. Its structured approach can safely access and reprocess dissociative memories, leading to significant symptom reduction.

Phobias

EMDR is often used to treat specific phobias, especially those rooted in past traumatic or distressing experiences. By reprocessing the memory that underlies the phobia, EMDR can reduce the phobic reaction.

Self-Esteem and Identity Issues

AEDP can effectively address issues related to self-esteem and identity. Its approach helps clients access and express their true selves, fostering self-acceptance and personal growth.

Relationship Issues

AEDP’s focus on relational dynamics makes it suitable for addressing relationship issues, enhancing emotional intelligence, and improving communication skills.

Chronic Pain and Somatic Symptoms

EMDR has shown efficacy in treating chronic pain and somatic symptoms, especially when they are associated with psychological factors. It helps in processing the emotional components of physical pain.

Schedule a Session with Liz Davis, LMFT Today

If the journey of healing and transformation speaks to you, and you're ready to explore the depths of your emotional landscape or confront and reprocess past traumas, there's no better time to start than now. As a compassionate and skilled Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist, I want to guide you through every step of this transformative journey. Whether through the nurturing approach of AEDP or the structured healing of EMDR, I offer a supportive and safe environment for your therapeutic journey.

Take the courageous step towards reclaiming your emotional well-being and inner peace. Click the button below to schedule your first therapy session with me in Kansas City today and embark on a path that leads to healing, growth, and a deeper understanding of yourself. Your journey to a more fulfilled and balanced life begins with this decision - an investment in yourself.

Resources to Learn More About AEDP and EMDR

For AEDP:

  • The book "The Transforming Power of Affect: A Model for Accelerated Change" by Diana Fosha, the founder of AEDP, is a seminal book that provides an in-depth understanding of the therapy’s theoretical foundations and practices.

  • AEDP Institute Website: The AEDP Institute (aedpinstitute.org) offers a wealth of information, including articles, training opportunities, and a directory of therapists trained in AEDP, including Liz Davis.

For EMDR:

Liz Davis
Previous

The Ultimate Guide to Self-Confidence
Next

Managing Holiday Stress: Empowering Strategies for Navigating the Winter Holiday Season.